BURLINGTON, Vt. — Ben & Jerry’s flavor gurus are having a bit of a conundrum, so they’re enlisting fans for help. From now until October 9, fans are encouraged to visit BenJerry.com and cast their vote to bring back a Limited Batch flavor. The winning flavor will appear in freezers nationwide this December.

Fans can vote for one of the following six flavors:

• Candy Bar Pie
• Chocolate Cherry Garcia
• Nutty Caramel Swirl
• One Love
• Peanut Butter Half Baked
• Phish It’s Ice…. Cream

How did Ben & Jerry’s come up with this spectacular six list? Each of our Gurus chose his or her favorite previous Limited Batch flavor to throw into the running. “We’re really excited to give our fans the chance to bring back a flavor, said flavor guru Haylee Nelson. “Sometimes, we just need a little help when we can’t decide ourselves.”